Understanding Our Unique Card Grading System From Pack To Protector To You™

When it comes to collecting cards, understanding the grading system can feel overwhelming. New and experienced collectors alike may struggle with the various grading scales and jargon used in the industry. Our goal is to clarify how we grade our cards so that you know exactly what to expect from each purchase. This post explains our unique grading system and what each tier means for collectors.

©2025 Randy's Vault LLC

Our Grading Tiers

At the top of our grading system is "New, from pack." This grade indicates that a card has been taken directly out of a factory-sealed pack and placed immediately into a protective sleeve. It has not been touched by anyone except for one gloved hand after leaving the factory. We take pride in this process, as it ensures the card remains in flawless condition. For example, a 2021 Topps Series 1 Mike Trout card graded "New" could potentially increase in value by 20% over time compared to similar cards that have not been preserved as well. Our motto, "From Pack, To Protector, To You™," perfectly embodies our commitment to quality.

The next tier in our system is "Pristine." Cards that achieve this grade are free of any visible flaws. Collectors aiming to add perfectly conditioned cards to their collections often seek them out. An example would be a Mint Condition 2018 Panini Prizm Luka Dončić rookie card, which can fetch upwards of $1,500 in this grade.

After "Pristine," cards are classified as "Excellent." Though they may lack visible flaws, they might display minor imperfections such as slight surface dirt or a hint of yellowing. These issues are often minor enough that avid collectors appreciate these cards for their historical significance and storytelling—similar to how a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card holds immense value despite not being in perfect form.

Following this, there is the "Very Good" grade. Cards in this category may exhibit noticeable edge or corner wear along with minor flaws that are not very distracting. Collectors who value the character of each card often find these to be gems. For instance, a 1969 Mets team card with some wear might still be valued at $200, depending on market trends.

Lastly, we offer the "Good" grade. This designation is rare as it reflects a card with one or two noticeable flaws. Many cards in this state are typically discarded, yet we believe in offering options for collectors interested in cards that embody stories and history. For example, a 1977 Topps Reggie Jackson card may sell for less than $75, but it carries a significant narrative that appeals to many fans.

©2025 Randy's Vault LLC

Our Commitment to Quality

A few critical aspects set our grading system apart. We take our commitment to authenticity seriously. We never clean or trim any of our cards, ensuring they retain their original state. This allows collectors to appreciate them as they were meant to be seen.

Our confidence in the quality of our cards is backed by a 7-day money-back guarantee on every purchase. We understand that the card you receive must meet your expectations. If it doesn't, we will gladly refund your money, no questions asked.

Transparency remains a cornerstone of our service. We always disclose known issues with our cards. This practice helps you make informed decisions about your collection. Our website is run by passionate sports fans who understand the dedication of collectors. If we fail to meet your expectations, we are eager to make it right.

Wrapping It Up

Understanding our distinctive card grading system is crucial for any collector looking to elevate their collection. Our grading tiers—"New, from pack," "Pristine," "Excellent," "Very Good," and "Good"—offer clear insights into each card’s condition. With our focus on authenticity, transparency, and customer satisfaction, you can confidently trust the quality of the cards you receive.

Whether you're an experienced collector or just starting, we invite you to explore our offerings. Every card comes with a 7-day money-back guarantee, allowing you to shop confidently. Thank you for being a vital part of our community, and happy collecting!